News

5 Key Factors to Consider Before Choosing a Transformer

Meta Description: Use this practical checklist to select the right transformer for your project. We break down the 5 essential criteria: location, safety, ratings, cost, and regulations.

Choosing between a dry-type and an oil-immersed transformer involves more than just comparing price tags. It's about finding the right technical and economic fit for your specific project. Use this list of five key factors to guide your decision-making process.

1. Installation Location: Indoor vs. Outdoor

This is the most decisive factor.

• Indoor: Dry-type transformers are almost always mandatory due to their superior fire safety. They require no vaults, containment, or special ventilation systems.

• Outdoor: Oil-immersed transformers are typically the preferred choice. They are cost-effective, efficient, and their safety considerations (like oil containment) are easily managed in an outdoor setting.

2. Safety and Environmental Regulations

Consider the risk profile of the installation site.

• Fire Code: Buildings with high occupancy (hospitals, schools) or high-value assets (data centers) have strict fire codes that favor dry-types.

• Environmental Policy: Sites near waterways or with strict environmental policies may avoid oil-filled units to eliminate any risk of soil contamination.

3. Power Rating (kVA) and Efficiency

• Rating: Dry-type units are common up to ~10 MVA. For larger ratings, oil-immersed transformers are often the only practical or economical option.

  Efficiency: Evaluate the transformer's losses (no-load and load loss). A more efficient unit has a higher initial cost but lower operating costs. Calculate the Total Cost of Ownership.

4. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

Look beyond the purchase price:

• Initial Cost: Oil-immersed often wins for high power.

• Installation Cost: Dry-type can be simpler indoors; oil-immersed may require containment.

• Operating Cost: Energy losses represent the largest cost over the transformer's life.

  Maintenance Cost: Oil-immersed transformers require regular oil testing and analysis.

5. Standards and Customer Specifications

Finally, the choice may be dictated by:

• International Standards (IEC, IEEE, ANSI)

  Local Utility Requirements

• End-Customer Specifications in EPC contracts.

• Still Unsure? Let Us Help

This checklist is a starting point. The experts at Qinghao Electric can help you weigh these factors against your specific project requirements and budget.

Contact our engineering team today for a personalized recommendation.